Bruce Herbert on shareholder engagement success at DuPont
Recorded at Unitarian Universalist Church, Seattle, on August 30, 2009.
Bruce Herbert tells the story of a successful shareholder engagement with DuPont. Instead of simply selling shares in protest, shareholder engagement led DuPont to stop a 50-year-long strip mine operation near the magnificent and celebrated Okefenokee National Wildlife Refuge.
HERE IS A TRANSCRIPT:
I wanted to tell one quick story of a great success that we had just to illustrate what can be done. The DuPont Corporation, a $45 billion-a-year company, had a plan to conduct a strip mining operation alongside the entire eastern border of the Okefenokee National Wildlife Refuge. Now, they were mining for the seventh most common mineral on the planet, something called titanium dioxide.
It whitens paper, paint, and toothpaste. And it's extremely common, yet the company was saying that, well, we actually can't find it anywhere else, and we've tried, and we can't find it anywhere else, and we have to mine here. This was going to be a 50-year-long operation going around the clock, 24-7.
Now, the Okefenokee, has anyone been to the Okefenokee? Wow, that's terrific. It is beautiful. We went there on our honeymoon, actually.
And it's an extraordinary place, and it has the unique hydrology of the region. People come from all over the world to study and the species that live there. Well, when we went there, standing where these pieces of dredge mining equipment would be operating, I underhanded I could toss a ball into the waters of the swamp.
To say that it would not impact the unique ecology of that region was just a foolish thing. Well, it was about a three-year-long negotiation. The Sierra Club hired us to come do this, and everybody and their brother was against this, including the governor of Georgia, a whole array of community and environmental organizations.
The then-Secretary of Interior blew down and had a press conference against this project. But the company was adopting an attitude of, if we don't mine, it will be a taking from our company. And they said they were going to earn hundreds of millions of dollars, and they wanted to be recompensed if they were not going to mine.
And so they pushed this for a long time, and everyone was stymied. But as a shareholder, we came in, and with a Wall Street background, I thought about that a little bit, and we actually were successful in developing a mole inside the company. Don't tell anybody.
They were able to confirm some of our assumptions so that then I was able to go into a meeting with Paul Thiebaud, who they'd been playing a good cop, bad cop, and he would literally wrap the table and say this will be a taking from our company if we don't mine. Who will recompense us? And I was able to say, Paul, don't be ridiculous. There was silence.
I don't think anyone had said something like that to him in a long time. And I said, Paul, this would only be a taking if these two pieces of dredge mining equipment never operated again, and no one has suggested that. We're simply saying lift them up, find another location, and mine there for the next 50 years.
The company will have all the profits they were going to have anyway. And as you're at it, while you're at it, you're talking about hundreds of millions of dollars, but that's over a 50-year period. If you divide that by 50 and compare that to the $45 billion a year of annual revenue, you're talking about a project that's generating less than two one-hundredths of one percent of our gross revenue.
And that's gross, not even net. And yet, the Okefenokee is an internationally known environmental gem. People come from all over the world to study it, and if you harm the Okefenokee, it has the potential of damaging our... And we talk about our when we're shareholders.
It's our company. You, Paul Thiebaud, work for us. It has the potential of damaging our brand reputation across every single product line.
Now, you're telling me that you're willing to risk the entire brand name of DuPont for two one-hundredths of one percent of revenue, and that we can actually find and make elsewhere just by moving the mining equipment? That, to us, doesn't make good economic sense. Paul Thiebaud never came to another meeting after that. And the company donated 16,000 acres of land to permanently protect that.
It's the largest conservation gift that was ever made in the history of the state of Georgia. As well, they donated five million dollars. We didn't ask for this, even, but they saw that it was in their interest to donate five million dollars for the creation of a world-class education center for all the people who come to study the Okefenokee.
And that infusion of capital has led to a transformation, an economic renaissance in a town that was just like our old town Forks out here, that was so economically washed out and destitute, you would not recognize it from that day until today. This is the power of shareholder activism. And I will say that if we had been a traditional social investor and said, DuPont, we don't like what you're doing, we're selling your shares, that mining would be happening today.